Value Guides

Fair Carat

Value Guides

Plain-English answers to one question: what is this stone actually worth? Each guide gives a clear verdict, a value rating out of five, and an honest price range — never a single tempting figure.

GOOD VALUE

Aquamarine

Colour is everything — pale vs deep “Santa Maria” blue.

AFFORDABLE

Amethyst

Abundant and cheap — pay for colour grade, not carat.

DON’T OVERPAY

Citrine

Most “citrine” is heat-treated amethyst. Here’s the fair price.

CHEAP

Tiger’s Eye

Pay only for a sharp chatoyant “eye” — not dye or glass.

INEXPENSIVE

Carnelian

Mostly heat-treated/dyed agate. Pay for natural translucency.

IT DEPENDS

Garnet

From $5/ct red to $5,000/ct green — the type is everything.

OFTEN OVER-PRICED

Carved Gemstones

Workmanship vs material — what you actually pay for.

BUYER BEWARE

Gemstone Spheres

Size and dye tricks, and the fair price for a decorative orb.

HUGE RANGE

Opal

Body tone & colour play decide everything.

GREAT VALUE

Peridot

Buy the green — a vivid olive is the premium.

TWO MARKETS

Topaz

Cheap treated blue vs rare imperial — know which.

BUY THE GLOW

Moonstone

A strong, clear blue sheen is the whole price.

AFFORDABLE

Labradorite

Rare flash colours command the premium.

BUY THE BLUE

Lapis Lazuli

Deep, even blue — and watch for dye.

NATURAL VS TREATED

Turquoise

Stabilized is cheap; fine natural is the prize.

CHEAP

Onyx

Dyed agate — the value is in the cut.

POOR INVESTMENT

Diamond

Lab-grown collapsed 90%. The 5th C is certification.

WIDEST PRICE GAP

Jade

Nephrite vs jadeite, and the Type A/B/C treatment scale.

BUY THE LUSTRE

Pearl

Lustre beats size — and nacre thickness is invisible.

CHEAP UNLESS…

Amber

Copal and plastic fakes, and the Burmese ethics problem.

NEARLY WORTHLESS

Obsidian

Volcanic glass. Pay for the sheen, or the carving.

OFTEN RECONSTITUTED

Malachite

Cheap, gorgeous — and never for elixirs.

ABUNDANT

Rose Quartz

Pay for the star, not the pink. And it fades.

NOT A RING STONE

Fluorite

Hardness 4, perfect cleavage. Buy the specimen.

GENUINELY SCARCE

Larimar

One mountainside. It fades — and Atlantis is invented.

ASK: SOLID OR TRIPLET?

Ammolite

Fossil nacre from Alberta. Almost always assembled.